I’ve been seeing so many butternut squash and pasta recipes on my feed lately and have been having some serrrrrrious cravings. But truthfully the thought of 1. cutting and seeding a squash 2. roasting and pureeing said squash 3. cooking shells to then stuff shells 4. then waiting an hour for everything to bake again… well you know that’s just not my style. So of course I had to figure out a way to simplify things and satisfy my cravings without spending all day cooking.
A few simple tricks cuts this prep time down to about 20 minutes (with 1 hour hands off bake time) and the result is all the same goodness and a gourmet meal without the fuss.
brown butter sage
butternut squash stuffed shells
Serves: 4
Time: ~45 minutes
Dishes: 1 pan
Style: one-pan dinner
but what about...
what soup should I use? any butternut squash you like that is flavorful enough to stand up on it’s own. I used the Pacific Foods organic variety and I also loved this with the Trader Joe’s Autumnal Harvest and the Pumpkin Bisque, albeit the flavor is slightly different. Make sure it is NOT concentrate soup, so it has water in it already and is soup that is ready to serve.
what to serve with: while this isn’t one of my usual “full meals” with a protein/veg etc, I’m fully on board with having just this pasta as a meal. You get some veggies from the squash and this is a thoroughly filling meal despite not having “proper protein ie meat/tofu etc”. Truthfully I served this with a bagged kale salad and it was divine. This would also be great aside some roast chicken.
I HATE butternut squash - can I use another flavor? absolutely, use tomato soup or marinara sauce and use basil instead of sage.
can I skip the toppings: I’d say opt for at least 1 - either do the cheese or the brown butter bread crumbs mix, but don’t skip both.
I don’t have the right sized dish: this recipe is pretty flexible, you can easily adjust the filling and toppings based on how many shells will fit in your dish, just ensure they’re covered fully with liquid before baking. I do recommend that whatever dish you do use, that you pack the shells fairly tight otherwise they float around and lose their filling.
housekeeping...
storing + reheating: this is best fresh but reheats great in the microwave for a day or 2. I like to drizzle on a bit of leftover soup if I have it before reheating to rehydrate things a bit.
make it gluten free: if you can find GF shells use those. If not try stuffing into a GF canneloni or rigatoni.
tools.
Cutting board (not my exact one but very similar)
ingredients.
For the shells
250 g XL shells
1 1/2 cups whole milk ricotta
1/2 cup grated parmesan
1 tbsp dried sage (or 3 tbsp fresh, finely chopped)
1 tsp salt
1/2 tsp pepper
2 cloves minced garlic
3-4 cups butternut squash soup
For the brown butter sage topping
3 tbsp salted butter
1/2 tbsp dried sage (or 2 tbsp fresh)
1 cup panko bread crumbs
2 cups grated mozzarella
steps.
Make your filling.
Preheat oven to 400F.
To a bowl, add 1 1/2 cups ricotta, 1/2 cup shredded parmesan, 1 tbsp dried sage (or 3 tbsp fresh), 1 tsp salt, 1/2 tsp pepper and 2 cloves minced garlic and mix well.
Stuff your shells.
Pour a thin layer of your soup into your casserole dish. One at a time, stuff each shell with about 1 tbsp of mix - just enough to fill it. Place stuffed side up in a uniform single layer in your casserole dish.
You may have a few shells that aren’t stuffable - just save those ones for another time - or break a piece off the side to be able to fill
Gently pour remaining soup over the shells along with 1/2 cup water. Your shells should be fully submerged but not floating - add more soup if you have it, or water if needed. Cover dish with tin foil and bake for 1 hour.
Make your brown butter sage breadcrumbs.
Melt 3 tbsp butter in a small frying pan over medium heat, stirring constantly, until golden brown and bubbling has subside a bit, about 5-7 minutes. As soon as the butter starts to brown, add sage (if using fresh let it cook until the sizzling stops - about 20 seconds, if using dried add panko immediately), and 1 cup panko. Cook until panko is golden, stirring frequently with a spatula, about 3 minutes. Once deeply golden, pour into a bowl to stop the cooking. Set aside. Grate your mozzarella now.
Finish up.
Remove foil from shells. Top with cheese, then bread crumbs. Bake for another 10-15 minutes until the cheese is fully melted. Remove and let sit for 5 minutes before serving.
substitutions.
⚠️ Important note: if a substitute isn’t listed below, I don’t recommend omitting or replacing that ingredient, as it will significantly change the final dish.
XL shells: kind of the whole point but if you’re really struggling to find these, make canneloni instead.
full fat ricotta: I haven’t tried but I think a higher fat cottage cheese could work here.
sage: sub thyme but 1/2 the amount.
fresh garlic: sub 1 tsp garlic powder.
salted butter: use unsalted but add 1/2 tsp salt after the breadcrumbs are cooked.
panko bread crumbs: these are best for the nice crunch but regular breadcrumbs will work in a pinch
mozzarella: gruyere or gouda would be a nice substitue, even white cheddar.
butternut squash soup: any ready to eat soup (not soup from concentrate) will work, you may need to adjust the spice you use as sage doesn’t work with everything. Shoot me a message and I can help you figure it out. Anything else? Drop a comment below if you have any questions, and don’t forget to drop a note in the group chat if you do make it!
With love from Reggie and her stick pic of the week 🫶



